Grade 10 · Reading & language
Notice gaps in an argument practice
Identify why a reason does not adequately support a conclusion.
Opening your practice adventure…
Try a sample
READ THE PASSAGE
When asked whether the path is accessible, the organizer replies that the flowers are attractive.
What is the main reasoning problem?
- It attacks the person instead of the idea.
- It treats popularity as proof.
- It draws a broad conclusion from too little evidence.
- It changes the subject.
See the answer & why
It changes the subject.
The response does not address the path's accessibility.
A little hint: Separate the conclusion from its evidence and check whether the evidence actually supports it.
A teaching tip
Separate the conclusion from its evidence and check whether the evidence actually supports it.